How mass BitTorrent lawsuits work and what to do if you receive a notice about one.
Estimated Read Time: 6 minutes
A copyright troll is a copyright owner that makes money primarily by filing mass federal lawsuits, often targeting people it knows only by their IP addresses. If your internet provider sent you a letter about a BitTorrent lawsuit, the company behind it may fit this description.
Reddit discussions often dismiss copyright troll lawsuits as scare tactics, but ignoring an ISP notice can leave you with less time to consider your legal options. The first few weeks can be especially important, so start by finding out who filed the lawsuit and what the case involves.
In this article, you will learn:
- How copyright trolls use an IP address to file a lawsuit
- What sets these plaintiffs apart from ordinary copyright owners
- Why federal judges still issue subpoenas in these cases despite the troll label
- How the lawsuit affects the deadline in your ISP letter
How a Copyright Troll Builds a Lawsuit
Copyright trolls in BitTorrent cases follow a familiar process. They use monitoring software to record IP addresses associated with alleged file sharing. The plaintiff can then file a federal lawsuit against an unnamed defendant, known as a “John Doe,” and ask a judge for permission to subpoena the internet provider for the subscriber information tied to that IP address.
Here is what typically happens at each stage of a copyright troll lawsuit:
How Copyright Trolls Differ From Other Copyright Owners
Filing a copyright lawsuit does not automatically make a company a copyright troll. Critics use the term when a plaintiff appears to rely on mass litigation and settlement payments as a business model. Federal copyright law does not define “copyright troll” as a legal category, and the label does not give a defendant an automatic defense.
Compare common copyright enforcement practices with the tactics critics associate with copyright trolling:
Why the ‘Troll’ Label Does Not End a Lawsuit
Online forums often suggest that judges recognize copyright trolls and dismiss their cases. A 2018 ruling against adult movie company Strike 3 Holdings seemed to support that idea. Judge Royce Lamberth denied the company’s subpoena request and wrote that its lawsuits “smack of extortion.”
Strike 3 appealed, and the D.C. Circuit reversed the decision in 2020. The appeals court found that the judge had not properly applied the legal standard for early discovery. The ruling allowed Strike 3 to pursue subscriber information despite the concerns about its litigation practices.
The following table compares common claims about copyright troll lawsuits with what federal courts have actually allowed.
What Happens After You Receive an ISP Letter
If you receive a letter from your ISP, your options can change as the copyright lawsuit advances.
Here is how settlement demands may increase and how your position changes at each stage.
What to Check Before You Accept a Settlement Offer
A settlement offer can resolve a copyright lawsuit, but the agreement determines what happens after you pay. Review the terms carefully before you sign.
- Release of claims: Check which copyright claims the plaintiff agrees to release and whether the release covers all works listed in the lawsuit.
- Dismissal of the case: Confirm when the plaintiff must dismiss the lawsuit and whether the dismissal will be with prejudice.
- Payment terms: Check the amount, due date, and whether the plaintiff allows installments.
- Confidentiality: Look for restrictions on discussing the settlement.
- Admission of liability: Check whether the agreement requires you to admit infringement or accept other findings.
An attorney can review the agreement and explain what rights you give up before you sign.
Further Reading
Talk To a Copyright Troll Defense Lawyer
Antonelli Law® has represented more than 5,000 clients in BitTorrent copyright cases since 2010. Our attorneys can review your ISP letter and discuss your options before the response deadline.
Attorney-client privilege protects everything you share, even if you don’t hire us.