Share: f X in @

What copyright trolls do between a download and a settlement demand.

Estimated Read Time: 6 minutes

Critics use the term “copyright troll” for media companies that file large numbers of lawsuits against anonymous internet subscribers and rely on early settlements for much of their revenue. The process often starts with tracking alleged downloads and ends with a demand for payment, but several legal steps can happen in between.

Most people first learn about the copyright troll lawsuit model when their internet service provider (ISP) notifies them that a federal lawsuit has issued a subpoena. Online discussions, especially on Reddit, often leave them confused about deadlines and what happens next. Understanding how everything works helps you assess your options before your ISP reveals your identity to the company.

In this article, you will learn:

  • What a copyright troll lawsuit involves
  • Why copyright holders like Strike 3 Holdings file thousands of lawsuits
  • Which parts of the model face the greatest challenges in federal court
  • How the timing of your response affects settlement costs

How a Copyright Troll Lawsuit Works

Cases like these follow a similar sequence, and the plaintiff (the copyright holder) usually controls what happens until you respond to them. Here is how a case typically unfolds:

Stage What Happens Your Status
Monitoring The plaintiff logs IP addresses that share its movies or other content over BitTorrent Anonymous
John Doe lawsuit The plaintiff files a federal complaint that identifies you by your IP address Anonymous
Early discovery The plaintiff asks the court for permission to subpoena your ISP Anonymous
ISP notice Your ISP notifies you about the subpoena and gives you a response deadline Still anonymous, with a deadline
Identity disclosure The plaintiff receives your name and decides whether to pursue or dismiss the case Not anonymous
Amended complaint The plaintiff files a complaint naming you as a defendant and serves a summons Not anonymous, but the court may keep your name under seal

Strike 3 Holdings Lawsuits and Settlement Figures

Strike 3 Holdings, an adult film company, has filed thousands of copyright infringement lawsuits against internet subscribers accused of sharing its films. The figures below summarize reported filing numbers and settlement demands.

Strike 3 Holdings Metric Figure
Federal lawsuits filed since 2017 More than 20,000
Lawsuits filed in 2024 3,932
States with filings About 22
Movies per lawsuit At least 23, often 25–75
Opening settlement demand $750 per movie
Demand after an amended complaint About $1,500 per movie

What’s Wrong With the Copyright Troll Model

Copyright troll lawsuits face several legal challenges that can affect the plaintiff’s case and the defendant’s potential liability. The main weaknesses involve the evidence linking a subscriber to a download, the damages a court may award, and the rules governing public court records.

An IP address does not identify the downloader

An IP address does not establish who downloaded the alleged files. In Cobbler Nevada, LLC v. Gonzales (2018), the Ninth Circuit held that a subscriber’s status alone does not support a reasonable inference that the subscriber committed the infringement.

A plaintiff needs additional evidence to link the defendant to the alleged activity. Someone else using the network, such as a minor, could account for the downloads described in an ISP notice.

Damages figures depend on willfulness

Federal copyright law allows statutory damages of $750 to $30,000 per work, as the court considers just. A court may award up to $150,000 per work if the plaintiff proves willful infringement. An ISP notice alone does not establish willfulness.

A defendant who proves they had no knowledge of the infringement and no reason to believe their conduct violated copyright law may qualify for reduced statutory damages.

Federal judges have pushed back

In 2018, a federal judge in Washington, D.C., called Strike 3 Holdings a “copyright troll” and denied its request for early discovery to identify an ISP subscriber. In 2020, the D.C. Circuit reversed the ruling because the district court had relied on improper factors when denying the request.

Strike 3 sometimes asks courts to keep amended complaints under seal to protect defendants’ identities from public disclosure. Judges decide whether to grant those requests.

How Timing Affects Settlement Costs

Plaintiffs may offer lower settlements early in a case because litigation costs can increase as the case progresses. Settlement amounts typically increase 20–40% after a defendant has been served with a summons and amended complaint, compared to early-stage negotiations. Settlement amounts vary by case, so treat these figures as reported examples, not guaranteed rates.

If a process server delivers a summons and amended complaint, respond before the court’s deadline. Ignoring service puts you at risk of a default judgment.

Here is how the timing of your response can affect factors like your potential settlement cost:

Action Timing Negotiating Position Anonymity Protection Typical Settlement Range
Before your ISP releases your information You may have more options to negotiate anonymously Your identity remains undisclosed to the plaintiff May be lower
After disclosure, before service You may still negotiate before formal service The plaintiff knows your identity, but public disclosure may remain limited Varies by case
After the plaintiff serves you You must respond by the court’s deadline Your name may appear in public court records Typically 20–40% higher

Further Reading

Talk Through Your ISP Notice Before the Deadline

Received an ISP subpoena in a copyright troll case? Check the date on your letter to know how much time you have to respond.

At Antonelli Law®, we have defended BitTorrent copyright cases in federal court since 2010, and nearly 100% of our clients resolve their cases without going to court. Our team can explain your options and help you understand what to expect before you decide how to respond.

Your consultation is completely confidential and covered by attorney-client privilege, even if you do not hire us.